This post on ‘The Stagnancy State: Addressing Decline of Church Attendance’ is part of a series on Growing The Church: The Life Cycle of a Church. This post looks at the characteristics of one of the stages of life a church can go through – the stagnancy stage.
The other posts in the series are:
The stagnancy stage is a pivotal moment in the life cycle of a church, often marked by the decline of church attendance, waning finances, and growing resistance to change. A river or lake is said to be stagnant when it has no inlet and no outlet, meaning there is no freshness coming into it and no life flowing from it. This may sound harsh, but describes a stagnant church well. There is no new life coming into it, and the only life coming from it are those who are leaving the church.
This stage represents the first visible signs of deterioration, as the church begins to lose not only attendees but also the visionaries, pioneers, and creatives essential for its future. While this is a challenging phase, it’s also an opportunity for renewal. With the right leadership, a compelling vision, and a willingness to embrace change, the stagnancy stage can become a turning point.
This blog will explore the stagnancy stage in depth, examining its key characteristics and offering insights into how churches can navigate this season to overcome the decline of church attendance and rediscover their purpose.
What is the Stagnancy Stage of a Church and Why Is It Linked To A Decline of Church Attendance?
Churches in the stagnancy stage often find themselves trapped in a cycle of nostalgia, bureaucracy, and declining momentum. Methods and practices that once worked have become entrenched, and attempts to introduce change are frequently met with resistance. This is a season where sacred cows—long-standing traditions and systems—are fiercely protected, even as they contribute to the church’s struggles.
The stagnancy stage is characterised by two major challenges:
-
- A noticeable decline in church attendance and giving.
- A leadership vacuum, as innovative and forward-thinking leaders are often driven away or leave voluntarily due to frustration.
Without a radical shift in leadership, vision, and culture, stagnancy can push a church further into decline. However, it is possible to reverse this trend by addressing its root causes. Let’s examine the eight key characteristics of churches in the stagnancy stage and consider practical steps for revitalisation.
1. Strategy: Maintaining the Status Quo
In the stagnancy stage, a church’s strategy often shifts from growth to maintaining. Leaders focus heavily on keeping the remaining members from leaving, especially those who are vocally supportive, influential, or financially generous. This defensive posture creates a culture of appeasement rather than innovation. Programmes, worship styles, and traditions are maintained not because they’re effective but because they satisfy long-standing members.
This strategy, while understandable, can alienate younger members or those seeking meaningful change. Instead of fighting to retain members through outdated methods, churches must adopt a forward-thinking strategy that prioritises vision and mission. This requires courage to let go of what no longer serves the church and invest in initiatives that align with its purpose and community needs.
2. Culture: Nostalgia and Resistance to Change
A culture of nostalgia often dominates stagnant churches. Leaders and members long for the “golden age” of the church, whether that was 10, 20, or even 50 years ago. This backward focus fuels resistance to change, as members cling to methods and traditions that once worked but are no longer effective.
Blame becomes a recurring theme in this culture. External factors such as societal shifts, other churches, or declining moral standards are often blamed for the church’s struggles. Internally, leaders who challenge the status quo or introduce new ideas may face criticism or dismissal.
To move forward, churches must foster a culture of openness and adaptability. Instead of longing for the past, leaders should guide the congregation to embrace the possibilities of the future, encouraging creativity and collaboration.
3. Focus: Challenges, Inside and Out
Churches in the stagnancy stage often become problem-focused. Internally, they concentrate on issues such as declining attendance, dwindling finances, and fractured ministries. Externally, they fixate on perceived threats, such as societal changes or competition from other churches. This problem-centric mindset creates a sense of hopelessness and stifles innovation. It’s not unusual to see stagnant churches detached and withdraw from wider societal involvement and engagement, adopting a ‘come to us’ mentality rather than a biblical ‘go out into the world‘ mindset.
The antidote to this focus is a shift towards opportunities. Churches need to identify areas where they can make a positive impact and develop solutions that address both internal challenges and external opportunities. This requires a mindset change from survival to mission-driven growth.
4. Leadership: Controlled by Committees
In stagnant churches, leadership is often dictated by boards or committees, leaving senior leaders with limited authority. These leaders are expected to “tow the line,” adhering to entrenched practices and traditions rather than driving meaningful change. This creates frustration for visionary leaders and discourages innovation.
To revitalise leadership, churches must empower their leaders to lead. Boards and committees should act as partners, providing guidance and support while allowing leaders the freedom to implement bold, strategic changes. In some cases, this may require restructuring leadership roles or replacing entrenched board members.
5. Ministry: Preserving What’s Left
Ministries in stagnant churches focus on preservation rather than growth. Programmes and events are maintained as long as resources allow, often competing for dwindling volunteers and finances. This competition creates tension within the church and leads to a decline in overall effectiveness.
Churches must adopt a ministry strategy that prioritises mission-aligned activities. This involves evaluating existing programmes and letting go of those that no longer serve the church’s purpose. By simplifying ministry efforts and focusing on core priorities, churches can maximise their impact and reduce internal conflict.
6. Structure: Bureaucracy Over Mission
Rigid structures and bureaucracy often dominate stagnant churches. Constitutions, bylaws, and policies are frequently used as tools to block change or enforce decisions, depending on the agendas of whoever holds power. Staff reductions are common, leaving remaining employees overburdened and expected to cover multiple roles.
To overcome this, churches must streamline their structures and prioritise mission over bureaucracy. Flexibility and adaptability should guide decision-making processes, empowering leaders and teams to act quickly and effectively. Simplified structures allow the church to focus on its vision rather than getting bogged down in politics and procedures.
7. Finances: A False Sense of Security
Financial decline is a hallmark of the stagnancy stage. While savings, reserves, or large gifts from dedicated members can create a false sense of security, the reality is often unsustainable. Churches may continue to operate as usual until the financial strain becomes undeniable, leading to abrupt and often painful cuts.
Transparency and stewardship are essential for addressing financial challenges. Churches must develop a realistic financial strategy that aligns with their mission and goals. This includes prioritising resources for growth-oriented initiatives and reducing reliance on unsustainable practices.
8. Growth Engine(s): Reboot
The stagnancy stage represents a critical moment for recognising the reality of the church’s situation. Growth becomes possible only when leaders and congregants acknowledge the need for change and commit to a turnaround strategy. This often involves hiring or empowering leaders with genuine authority, developing a fresh vision, and uniting the congregation around a shared mission.
Turnaround efforts may require painful decisions, such as letting go of ineffective programmes or restructuring leadership. However, these steps are necessary for creating a foundation for sustainable growth. Without full support from the congregation and leadership, even the best strategies will fail.
Revitalising a Stagnant Church Facing A Decline of Church Attendance
The stagnancy stage does not have to lead to further decline. With intentional effort, churches can reverse the trend and rediscover their purpose. Here are some practical steps for revitalisation:
-
- Embrace a Fresh Vision: Develop a compelling vision that inspires and unites the congregation.
- Empower Leaders: Give leaders the authority and support they need to implement change.
- Simplify Ministry Efforts: Focus on core priorities and eliminate activities that drain resources without bearing fruit.
- Foster a Culture of Openness: Encourage dialogue, creativity, and collaboration to break free from nostalgia and resistance.
- Prioritise Stewardship: Develop a transparent financial strategy that aligns with the church’s mission and goals.
By taking these steps, churches can move beyond stagnancy and build a future marked by growth, impact, and renewed purpose.
Final Thoughts on the Decline of Church Attendance
The stagnancy stage is a challenging season in the life of a church, but it also represents an opportunity for renewal. Addressing the decline of church attendance requires courage, humility, and a willingness to embrace change. By focusing on mission, empowering leadership, and uniting the congregation around a shared vision, churches can turn this stage into a stepping stone towards a brighter future.
Next Steps If You Are Facing A Decline of Church Attendance
If your church is experiencing stagnancy, ask yourself:
-
- Are we willing to let go of outdated methods and embrace new opportunities?
- Are we empowering leaders to lead boldly and effectively?
- Are we prioritising mission over tradition and bureaucracy?
The answers to these questions can determine whether your church continues to decline or experiences a revitalising transformation.
This post is part of a series on Growing The Church: The Life Cycle of A Church. The other posts in the series are:
I’ve also developed a Next Steps Navigator assessment, which will tell you what stage of the lifecycle your church is currently in, as well as give you key steps to take and things to avoid to successfully navigate your currently season. Click HERE to discover the stage of growth your church is at.
